What is a scientific merit review?

What is a scientific merit review?

Q: What is Scientific Merit Review (SMR)? Scientific Merit Review (SMR) is a process that is intended to ensure that research is of sound design and methodology and is likely to contribute to literature in the discipline or field. Learners must obtain SMR approval in order to complete Dissertation Milestone 5.

How do you review an article scientifically?

Your review should follow the following structure:

  1. Abstract. Write this last.
  2. Introduction. Introduce your topic.
  3. Body. Can take different forms depending on your topic.
  4. Discussion/Conclusion. Restate your thesis.
  5. References. Make sure your references are formatted correctly and all present.

How do you evaluate a review article?

How to evaluate articles

  1. Authority/authorship.
  2. Currency/timeliness.
  3. Coverage/relevance.
  4. Purpose/audience.
  5. Accuracy/documentation.
  6. Objectivity/thoroughness.

What is scientific merit review NIH?

The SRO is responsible to the NIH for the scientific and technical peer review of grant applications and contract proposals. Ensures fair and unbiased evaluation of the scientific and technical merit of the proposed research.

What is an NIH scientific review group?

The mission of the Center for Scientific Review (CSR) is to see that NIH grant applications receive fair, independent, expert, and timely scientific reviews — free from inappropriate influences — so NIH can fund the most promising research.

How do you read and review a scientific journal article?

Step-by-step instructions for reading a primary research article

  1. Begin by reading the introduction, not the abstract.
  2. Identify the BIG QUESTION.
  3. Summarize the background in five sentences or less.
  4. Identify the SPECIFIC QUESTION(S)
  5. Identify the approach.
  6. Now read the methods section.

How do you evaluate the relevance of an article?

Knowing the discipline of an article is an important clue in determining relevance. You may be able to tell from the title of the book/article or the journal title. If you are researching global warming activism for a political science class, an article on global warming from a chemistry journal will not be relevant.

Who are NIH reviewers?

If you are an established and respected investigator, consider joining a peer review group at the NIH Center for Scientific Review to evaluate NIH grant applications for scientific merit. Your efforts will help advance science and ultimately improve public health and save lives.

What is NIH SRG?

NIH Scientific Review Group (SRG) Roster Index. The initial step of the peer review process takes place in Scientific Review Groups (SRGs) that are managed by the Institutes and Centers that are components of the NIH.